
Josh grew up in Bellville, Ohio. He received his undergraduate degree in Business Administration with a minor in Finance while attending Ohio Dominican University. At ODU, Josh started for the varsity football team for three years. Josh went on to complete his master’s degree in Business from Ohio Dominican University in 2010. Following Ohio Dominican, Josh attended Capital University Law School, where he received his law degree in the fall of 2015.
Josh has been with Pencheff and Fraley Co., LPA since 2015. Josh has experience handling a wide range of civil cases but focuses his practice on representing individuals who are applying for Social Security and Workers’ Compensation, as well as those individuals who have been injured and making a Personal Injury claim. In addition to these primary practices, Josh has experience handling contract disputes, employment discrimination, eminent domain defense, and insurance disputes.
Josh is a member of the Ohio and Columbus Bar Association. Josh lives in Blacklick with his wife, Brett, and their three sons: James, Brayden, and Owen. In his spare time, Josh enjoys spending time with his family, Ohio State athletics, and playing golf.
REAL PEOPLE, REAL STORIES
“I have had the privilege of working with Attorney Ray on three separate occasions, and each time he has delivered outstanding results. Typically, I am not inclined to write reviews after just one or two experiences, but Ray’s unwavering dedication and exceptional outcomes compel me to share my positive experiences.”
“I cannot thank Pencheff and Fraley enough for the incredible support and dedication they provided during my personal injury case. From the very beginning, they demonstrated professionalism, compassion, and a deep understanding of the law. They kept me informed every step of the way, always making sure I felt comfortable and understood my options.”
“I could not have chosen a better attorney to handle my husband’s case after his serious accident. Brad is a true professional—reassuring, sympathetic, and dedicated. Amy was also fantastic, always returning our calls and answering every question. You guys are the best!”
“I can’t recommend this law firm enough! My car was hit by a semi last year. It was a long recovery, and an exhausting process, but David Fraley helped immensely. He was professional, and very friendly. He was able to reach a favorable settlement for me. He was the only part of the entire process that was easy and stress-free.”
Injury and Accident Attorneys
© 2026 Pencheff & Fraley Injury and Accident Attorneys. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy *Client photos are illustrative only.